Heirloom Easter Recipes

Cover your table with perennial favorites

Old recipes tell a story. I collect and hold them dear like fond memories. Many remind me of a special person, time, or lesson in life. This Easter, allow me to share some of my most treasured recipes for your holiday table.


Nana’s Pineapple Cheese Casserole Recipe

I can’t recall an Easter celebration from my childhood that didn’t include Nana’s Pineapple Cheese Casserole. I suppose it’s only natural this time-tested favorite served as a comfort to my soul after I moved away from home. Over the years I’ve tried many variations of sides, however Pineapple Cheese Casserole stands as a tradition. It feels like home and is a fond reminder of Nana and her talent for cooking. Its sweet, cheesy goodness is the perfect compliment to a salty ham.


Mrs. Nolan’s Potato Salad Recipe

My favorite potato salad recipe came from our neighbor, Peggy Nolan. She lived across the street from us early in our marriage. Upon arriving home from the hospital with our newborn, Mrs. Nolan motioned to us from her driveway. Through cupped hands, she hollered, “I’ll bring dinner over in just a bit.” I recall tears welling due to her kindness and a never-to-be-forgotten meal of homemade rotisserie chicken, fresh green beans, and potato salad. She taught me what it means to extend hospitality. This version has a rustic, old-world flavor. Raw onions add a sharp bite to the palate, yet it’s light due to the sour cream. Best made a day ahead, it will bring ease to your day-of celebration.


Paula’s Coconut Cake Recipe

I recall one particular year, Easter didn’t line up with Spring Break, which usually provided us an opportunity to return home to family and our beloved Florida beaches. To curb my disappointment, I invited several families over after church for a meal together. When friends feel like family you know you’ve built a community. To ease my effort they all offered to contribute a dish to our Easter lunch. My friend, Sally, brought an impressive four-layer coconut cake — a handed-down recipe from her mother, Paula. This cake is incomparable in flavor and is the perfect holiday dessert as it too is prepared in advance. To this day, Paula’s Coconut Cake reminds me of the value of community.

As you gather this Easter to celebrate eternal life and the joys this life brings through family and friends, I hope you enjoy these heirloom recipes, remember some of your own, and cherish the stories that brought them to you.

Hugs out! Laura

Have any questions or would like to share a recipe?

I would Love to TALK. Just send me a message.

Subscribe for eNews updates on events, savings & new ONK blog releases

Join the conversation. Join the movement.

Together we can create a movement of essential conversations, healthy eating, and enjoying the company of loved ones and dear friends online and around kitchen tables around the country.

Your information is safe. We will only send you periodic goodies and helpful info we have found. Can’t wait to talk!

Scroll to Top